iGaming NewsNovember 21, 2026·CBy Chetana Jain

Judge Denies CFTC Bid to Halt New York's Kalshi Case

Judge Denies CFTC Bid to Halt New York's Kalshi Case

A federal judge has rejected the Commodity Futures Trading Commission's emergency bid to stop New York from pressing its enforcement case against Kalshi. U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield issued the denial on Friday. Her reasoning: the regulator hadn't shown a likelihood of success on the claim at the heart of its argument, which is that federal law bars states from applying gambling rules to prediction markets under federal oversight.

The denial came one day after a different federal judge granted New York's motion to send its Kalshi lawsuit back to state court. That procedural win matters more than it might look. It returns New York Attorney General Letitia James's request for a temporary restraining order to a state judge, and the New York County Supreme Court has scheduled a hearing on the request for Monday, November 23.

New York wants a TRO that would block Kalshi from offering sports event contracts in the state. Kalshi's position, repeated across more than 20 state cases now, is that its products are federally regulated derivatives under the CFTC's exclusive jurisdiction, and that this preempts state gambling law. The state's suit alleges Kalshi has been running unlicensed gambling operations in violation of New York law.

On November 20 the CFTC filed its emergency request. New York's proposed order, the commission argued, would reach far beyond the state's borders. The requested language would bar Kalshi from operating "within or from" New York. And since Kalshi is headquartered in the state, the commission contended the order would effectively shut the company down nationwide and posed an "existential threat" to its registrants, its marketplaces and its regulatory jurisdiction.

Schofield didn't accept that argument. Her reasoning leaned on the current split in the appellate courts: three have ruled against Kalshi, one has ruled in its favor, and whether the Commodity Exchange Act preempts state gambling regulation remains unresolved at that level.

Kalshi made its own case against the TRO in a November 19 letter filed right after the case returned to state court. The company asked the judge not to grant the order without hearing from both sides first. It also raised a conflict: an August CFTC directive requires Kalshi to keep running its exchange even if a court order tells it to block New York. That would leave the operator caught between federal and state commands.

New York's November 20 response rejected that framing. The attorney general's office accused Kalshi of repeatedly delaying enforcement while still collecting revenue from New York customers, and said the TRO would only stop the company from offering unlicensed gambling products, not shut it down nationwide. Two features of Kalshi's platform drew the state's attention: users under 21 can wager on sports, and they can bet on New York college teams. State sports betting law prohibits both.

Monday's hearing is where the TRO bid and Kalshi's objections get argued on the record. Until then, the practical position is unchanged. Kalshi keeps operating under federal registration, while New York's enforcement effort moves forward in state court. Operators watching the case should note the dates, because the November 23 hearing could produce an order with immediate effect on what Kalshi may offer to New York customers.

kalshicftcnew-yorkprediction-marketsevent-contractsregulationsports-betting